Guide
What scholarship markers look for in writing
Updated September 2026
Scholarship markers assess writing against a rubric, not a feeling. The rubric typically covers five areas: the quality of ideas, how the piece is structured, the range and precision of language, control of sentences and grammar, and the craft specific to the task type. Understanding what matters most in each area is the difference between practising with purpose and practising blind.
Ideas: specific beats general
The most common gap in scholarship writing is general claims without evidence. A student writes "Homework is bad for mental health" but does not explain how or offer a concrete example. A marker reads this as an assertion, not an argument. The student who writes "Three students in my class told the counsellor they could not sleep before the Friday maths sheet was due" gives the reader something to stop and think about.
At the top of the rubric, ideas are not just present but developed. Each reason leads somewhere. The reader learns something they did not expect. At the middle of the rubric, reasons are listed but not extended.
Structure: build, don't list
Many students learn a formula: introduction, three body paragraphs, conclusion. At scholarship level this is a floor, not a ceiling. Markers reward pieces where the structure serves the argument. A paragraph that responds to the one before it scores higher than a paragraph that simply introduces a new point.
The conclusion is where structure matters most. A conclusion that restates the introduction adds nothing. A conclusion that introduces a new angle, a broader implication, or a call to action shows the writer is still thinking at the end of the piece, not just wrapping up.
Language: precise beats fancy
Markers do not reward long words or complex vocabulary used for its own sake. They reward precise word choices. "The tree was cut down" is plain. "The council felled a sixty-year-old eucalyptus" is precise. The second version tells the reader more, not because the words are harder, but because they are more specific.
Crutch words are the easiest place to start. Words like "really," "very," "stuff," "things," and "a lot" take up space without adding meaning. Swap one per paragraph for a specific word and the difference in how the piece reads is immediate.
Sentence control: clean, not simple
Markers look for sentences that are correct and varied, not just short or just long. A piece written entirely in short sentences reads as choppy. A piece with only long sentences loses clarity. The strongest writers alternate: a short sentence for impact, a longer one for development.
Conventions (spelling, punctuation, grammar) are assessed, and they matter. But they rarely carry a piece on their own: strong ideas with a slip or two read better than perfect spelling with little to say. Repeated errors in comma use, tense, or pronoun reference are different. They make a piece harder to follow, and markers notice.
Task-specific craft: know the form
The fifth area changes depending on the task type. In persuasive writing, markers look for audience awareness, counter-arguments, and rhetorical devices. In creative writing, they look for characterisation through action, tension, and an ending that reshapes the story. In informative writing, they look for logical organisation and the ability to explain complexity clearly.
A student who writes a strong narrative when the prompt asks for a persuasive letter has misread the task. No amount of good writing overcomes a mismatched form. Reading the prompt carefully and identifying the task type before planning is a habit that saves marks.
The three most common mistakes
First, not planning. Students who start writing immediately produce pieces that wander. Five minutes of planning produces a piece that builds. Second, general claims without evidence. Every argument needs at least one specific detail that the reader cannot dismiss. Third, spending too long on the opening. The first sentence matters, but students who rewrite their opening three times run out of time for the conclusion, which is the last thing the marker reads.
See what a rubric-based mark looks like on your child's writing.
Sit one freeScholarship Practice is not affiliated with or endorsed by any test provider. All provider information is sourced from publicly available materials.