Ollie, Year 6 · persuasive, 25 min · 187 words

Developing well

Ideas
4/6

Reasons developed with supporting details. Each adds content the others do not.

Structure
5/6

Paragraphs follow an identifiable principle. Conclusion contains a call to action.

Words
3/6

Some precise vocabulary. Crutch words appear three times. Sentence length mostly uniform.

Sentences
4/6

No errors affecting meaning. One comma splice. Cohesion through logical connectives.

Persuading the reader
4/6

Reader addressed in their role. One device specific to audience. Counter-argument acknowledged.

Total20/30

Could be stronger. This sentence takes up space without adding new information. It could be cut or replaced with something more specific.

Reaching beyond the basics. This sentence attempts a technique or structure that goes beyond what is typical for the year level. It may not be perfect, but the attempt is what matters.

Dear Mr Papadopoulos, I strongly believe that homework should be banned from our school. I have three important reasons why.

Firstly, homework is very stressful.
Lots of kids in my class get worried about it and some of them even cry.1 We already do six hours of school work every day and then we have to do more at home. That is not fair.

Secondly, homework takes away family time.
My mum works late and when she gets home I am doing homework instead of talking to her. Family is more important than a maths sheet.

Thirdly, homework does not even help you learn.
If you already understand the work then doing it again at home is a waste of time. If you do not understand it then you are stuck at home with no teacher to help.2

Some people might say homework teaches responsibility but I think there are better ways to learn that, like chores or sport.3


In conclusion, I ask you to please consider banning homework.
The students of this school deserve to rest and spend time with their families after a long day of learning.
1

Show the evidence instead of claiming it

Ideas

"Lots of kids" asks the principal to take your word for it. A specific detail is harder to argue with.

Try it like this

Last term, four people in my class told the school counsellor they could not sleep because of the Friday maths sheet.

Rewrite this
2

Finish the thought you started

Ideas

You set up a strong argument but moved on before showing the principal what it looks like.

Try it like this

If you do not understand it then you are stuck at home with no teacher to help, staring at the same question for twenty minutes until your parent gets frustrated too.

Rewrite this
3

Give the counter-argument a real voice

Persuading the reader

"Some people might say" is vague. Name who holds this view and what they argue.

Try it like this

Teachers sometimes argue that homework teaches students to manage their time and take responsibility for their learning, but I think sport and household chores teach those skills better and without the stress.

Rewrite this

Next practice

Before you write your next piece, write one specific example under each reason before you write anything else.

For parents and caregivers

Ollie is writing with a clear structure and genuine voice, which is a real strength for Year 6. The area with the most room to grow is evidence: he makes good points but supports them with vague claims instead of specific details. That is the quickest thing to change because he clearly has the ideas. The counter-argument in the second-to-last paragraph shows he is already thinking about both sides. You do not need to worry about his spelling or sentence structure right now.

What the next level looks like

Dear Mr Papadopoulos,

I am writing to ask you to consider removing homework from our school. I have seen what it does to the students in my class and I believe it causes more harm than good.

My first concern is the stress it puts on students. Last term, four people in my class told the school counsellor they could not sleep the night before the Friday maths sheet was due. We already spend six hours a day learning at school. Adding more work at home means students have no time to rest, and a tired student the next morning learns less than a rested one.

Homework also takes time away from families. My mum finishes work at six o'clock, and by the time she gets home I am sitting at the kitchen table doing homework. We eat dinner in silence because I am still thinking about my assignment. That hour could be the only hour we have together all day.

Some teachers argue that homework teaches responsibility and helps students practise what they learned. I understand that argument, and they are right that practice matters. But there are better ways to build responsibility, like sport, chores, or reading a book you chose yourself, and none of those make a child cry at the kitchen table.

I ask you to try one term without homework and see what happens. I believe you will see happier students, better rested students, and families that have their evenings back.

Yours sincerely,

Ollie

This is a sample. Your child’s mark looks like this, about their own writing.

Get a free mark

Your first piece and one rewrite are marked free. No card needed.